Aurora Catholic High School Rankings &
Newmarket’s Best Catholic High Schools
UPDATE DEC 2022: Rankings for York Region North have been discontinued. Please continue to see school rankings for the following:
Mississauga
Oakville
Burlington
Etobicoke
West End/High Park area
Vaughan
Richmond Hill
Markham
Brampton
Milton
Georgetown
Hamilton
The best Catholic high schools in Aurora, Newmarket & the rest of York Region North are not that easy to gauge. The way many parents do it is by planning to attend Catholic high schools that have very-good-to-excellent pass-rates on the EQAO test scores the Ontario government publishes every year for all publicly-funded schools in the province. Others simply rely on the SUSI Rankings to at least get a decent sense of what the best Catholic high schools in York Region North might be.
RELATED: For York North Public High School Rankings, go here.

However, as Real Estate People who know a thing or two about schools, we strongly feel that there is a problem with making a determination about the “best” Catholic high schools in York North based solely on EQAO pass-rates. These test scores only emanate from Grade 9 and Grade 10 students… some who have attended the high school for only half a year! I wonder: How can you make a correct overall assessment of a high school based on these results alone?? The answer is: You cannot, and you really should not.
What could be just as a determining of a factor are the programs or clubs offered by each secondary school. Programs can be seen to work just as well as clubs in a secondary school to hopefully keep teenagers focused and out of trouble, and we have a full list of these programs available for our clients (they can be difficult to find at times on school board websites).
However, what the EQAO pass-rates are likely telling us is the general level of education of the incoming student population, and that has been a worthwhile concern for my clients, as well.

Aurora & Newmarket Catholic High School rankings have traditionally been “determined” by the Fraser Institute, but since their default rankings are only for the previous year, they can often be slightly misleading to concerned parents who seek consistency from a school – after all, if they are moving into a certain school district, more often than not they will be staying there for the duration of the child’s grade-school education.
This is part of the reason why we created the SUSI Rankings, which for high schools in York Region North involves heavy research into a school’s consistency in EQAO pass-rates over the years.
Keeping those thoughts in mind, here are the 2019 York North Catholic High School Rankings, as determined by our research:
THE BEST CATHOLIC HIGH SCHOOLS IN AURORA, NEWMARKET & KESWICK 2019
Rank | School | Grades | Score Ont avg = 1.000 |
---|---|---|---|
#1 | Sacred Heart [Newmarket] | 9-12 | 1.083 |
#2 | Cardinal Carter [Aurora] | 9-12 | 1.045 |
#3 | St Maximilian Kolbe [Aurora] | 9-12 | 1.016 |
#4 | Our Lady of the Lake [Keswick] | 9-12 | 0.862 |
These are the 4 Catholic high schools in York Region North, and they have been ranked like this based on 7-year EQAO test scores. However, please note that every high school will have its deficiencies and faults, just as every one of them will have glories and inspirations.
On our website, we also have full Catholic high school rankings for Vaughan, Markham and Richmond Hill, as well as for Mississauga, Oakville, Burlington, Milton, Georgetown, Brampton, Etobicoke, North York, Scarborough, and the City of Toronto. Check them out!
Searching for Real Estate in York North Catholic High School Districts
If you’re looking to purchase a home in a great high school district, don’t trust your search to any other Realtor out there. We here at SusiHomes always have the latest school boundaries and the latest school-district-demographics to help in your search. Plus you get immediate alerts in your email on any new homes in your preferred school districts, using only YOUR parameters to weed out the ones that you might not be able to afford, or don’t like because there aren’t enough bedrooms or perhaps even too many pools (ONE is too many for some!).
Contact us NOW to get your most-informed search started!
